02 Oct 2020

Why Positive Leadership and Organizational Culture Matter

This is a guest post by Marcella Bremer

Is there proof that organizational culture matters? Could it really determine performance? Let’s quickly look at the ground-breaking study of Professors John Kotter and James Heskett. They studied the corporate cultures of over 200 companies (including Hewlett-Packard, Xerox, ICI, Nissan, and First Chicago) and tracked their economic performances over an 11-year period.

What they found is fascinating: your culture can enhance economic success or make you fail to adapt to changing markets.

Does organizational culture matter?

Organizations with strong, shared company values increased their revenue on average to 682% over 11 years. Companies without a clear culture grew to just 166%. Heskett says that effective culture can account for 20-30 percent of the differential in corporate performance when compared with “culturally unremarkable” competitors.

[reference: James Heskett, The Culture Cycle - how to shape the unseen force that shapes performance (Pearson FT Press, 2015)

Many researchers looked at organizational performance, using a balance of financial and non-financial indicators. Think of profits and revenue, combined with job satisfaction, the error rate, quality and customer satisfaction. Organizational culture was found to directly impact the non-financial factors that contribute to organizational performance.

According to Bersin by Deloitte, 95% of employees say that culture is more important than compensation. Gallup research claims that only 13 percent of the global workforce is “highly engaged.” More than half the workforce would not recommend their employer to peers. Gallup also calculated that engaged people are 30% more productive.

"... only 13% of the global workforce is "highly engaged"..." (Gallup)

This is why employee engagement and culture are currently the number-1 challenge around the world (study by Deloitte). An overwhelming 87 percent of respondents believe the issue is “important”. Culture has been shown to impact the success of recruitment and retention, mergers and acquisitions, organizational change, and innovation.

Culture matters a lot! And it’s not just a strong culture that’s favorable. A positive culture can work wonders.

What’s the benefit of a positive culture?

Positive is productive. It affects the business bottom line, as research shows. Professor Kim Cameron at the University of Michigan has been researching positive organizations for years. He found that a positive climate, positive relationships, communication, and positive meaning lead to “positive deviance” or high performance.

The usual response to a problem is to go back to normal. But in a positive culture the focus is on what is working well and what people could do even better. A positive culture creates an “upward spiral” so it’s easier to achieve what is called Positive Deviance. People go the extra mile and might even surprise themselves.

"... in positive culture the focus is on what is working well and what people could do even better."

Let’s also bust a myth about “positive”: it is not soft and fake-happy. Positive cultures set challenging boundaries and targets to achieve Positive Deviance! People do not get away with slacking. A fake smile is not part of a positive culture, either. People are invited to be themselves but to focus on positive possibilities whenever possible. Negative feedback is part of the game but delivered in a constructive way.

Positive leaders change what is “normal”. Instead of problem-solving and returning to the zero-line, they aim for “positive deviance”. This is what companies such as Wells Fargo, Ford, Kelly Services, Burt’s Bees, Griffin Hospital, and Zingerman’s have been doing. They show that you can create positive change in your organization through simple actions and attitude shifts - thus developing the culture, organizational performance, and employee engagement. A Positive Culture can boost performance with 20% - and probably more.

What could you do today?

That’s great, but how do you go about it? “What if this doesn’t work with my team? You haven’t met my colleagues! You should see my boss!” The good news is that all people respond to positivity, even if they seem a bit suspicious or uncomfortable when you, for instance, give them a compliment. Of course, developing a positive culture with positive leadership takes more than handing out compliments. I started the online Positive Culture Academy to help leaders and organizations focus on what and who is working well, and to develop their culture with many more tools.

However, both research and my practice with clients confirm: your first step is to notice what goes well and to mention that! Catch your people doing something right, or appreciate them for being authentic, or helpful.

Giving well-meant compliments is a sure contribution to a (more) positive and productive culture. In the research by Losada and Heaphy, the single most important factor in predicting organizational performance turned out to be the ratio of positive to negative statements! Positive refers to appreciation, support, approval, or compliments. Who do you appreciate? Tell them! A recent Accenture study states that 43% people who leave their jobs, mentioned a lack of recognition as the reason…

[reference:  Kim Cameron, Practicing Positive Leadership, (Berrett-Koehler Publishers 2013)]

If you want to learn more, check out the Positive Culture Academy online curriculum, or see all courses available from the Positive Culture Academy

About the Author

Marcella Bremer MScBA is an author and culture consultant. She is the co-founder of the online Positive Culture Academy and the culture survey website OCAI Online.

Last updated: 02 Oct 2020

You might also be interested in:

Last updated: 4/8/2019

Why Author eLearning Content In-house Instead of Outsourcing?

If your company needs to develop e-learning content, you generally have two options: build courses in-house or outsource the process to third-party experts. Here are the benefits of creating courses within your company instead of outsourcing e-learning development.

Read more
Last updated: 9/3/2021

IT Managers as Mentors

In this guest post, Eric Bloom, Executive Director of ITML Institute, makes the case for why IT Managers should act as mentors, and how mentoring can benefit your employees, your organization and you.

Read more
Last updated: 10/19/2022

Top 6 Skills Every New Manager Needs

Whether you’re a new or aspiring manager, here are the top 6 skills that leaders from a range of industries believe are the most important for you to succeed.

Read more
Last updated: 1/19/2022

Coaching as a Development Tool

Wondering how you can stay better connected to your team? Coaching can be your best managerial tool for supporting your people's development. Read on to find out more.

Read more
Last updated: 11/30/2022

The Most Powerful Technique Leaders Use to Communicate Expectations Clearly

If you lead a team of people, you’ve almost certainly had the experience of your team failing to meet your expectations at some point. Want to change this? Use this highly effective technique to create crystalline understanding around your expectations, every time. 

Read more


Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion courses

See the list


Our newsletter
Leave your email and stay updated on professional training